I quite often get calls from Churches asking the question,
"How much should we pay a Youth Minister?"
Mostly this is a genuine question but one or two churches mean, What's the minimum we could pay and still get someone? Hence, across the Churches there is a massive range of salaries/stipends.
Being a Youth Minister for a Church is a tough call. The contracts can be short, worse still, things can suddenly come to an abrupt end. A new role normally means re-locating PLUS there is no real promotion prospects PLUS Churches think all Youth Ministers should be young! For these reasons a Church really needs to be providing accomodation and a fair wage (the accomodation is essential as Youth Ministers can't usually afford to move to the employing Parish, the fair wage being, I hope, a christian approach). A lot of Churches do provide an attractive renumeration.
I would nearly always recognise a Youth ministers complaints about lack of line management, moans about short-termism and gripes about projects ending too soon, however I've been surprised recently to hear a couple of youth ministers (from well paying churches) complain about their earnings.
Now lots of youth ministers have every right/need to be concerned about lack of pay but where the package is Accomodation plus Stipend, it's worth noting that it's a fair wage if you do the maths, and here I'm playing a heavens-advocate* a bit. (*Devil's-advocate didn't seem quite the right expression)
Lets say the house provided would otherwise cost £750 a month to rent, that's £9000 a year. Add on to that £1000 Council Tax and £300 Water Rates and that's £10,300 a year. If you are required to live in the house for the "better performance of duty" and you are employed as a minister, then this £10,300 is untaxed. Not only that but you'd have to earn £13,200 (in the real world) to leave you with that £10,300 after the Tax had been taken off. On top of this, a Stipend of around £16,000 is not unusual for these type of appointments. So in order to have the equivelant house/income in a secular role you'd (adding thse two figures together) need to be earning £29,200 (more in fact because the NI contributions would be much higher).
I've no wish to be shouted at by the youth worker/ministers who earn a lot less than this and I know there are FAR TOO MANY who do, I did however want to point out that for the good roles it is a fair renumeration.
I also think this figure is entirely justified because of the ad-hoc and often short term realities of working for a church, especially as Youth Ministers have none of the perks and support that clergy have. Further to this, although the package can be good it doesn't give ANY long term options i.e No job = no house.